When a number, quote or rule could change a decision, the bibliography is not enough. Pick the five claims you would least want to get wrong.
1. Pull out the claims
Extract the five claims in [report] most likely to affect [decision]. Quote each briefly and pair it with its cited source, if any. Separate facts, inference and recommendations. Do not invent a missing citation.
2. Check the evidence
For each claim, open the cited source if accessible. Record URL, page or section, scope, what you read (full primary source, abstract only, secondary source, or not accessed), and verdict (supported, partial, contradicted, unverified). Check dates, units and population; don't bypass restricted access.
3. Rewrite what you can defend
Rewrite [report] using the receipts. Narrow partial claims, remove or label unsupported ones and put citations next to the claims they support. End with the missing piece of evidence most likely to change the decision.
Try it on one example
If a memo says returns dropped 18%, look for whether the original table says 18 percent or 18 percentage points and whether it describes the pilot or all customers.
Inspired by a research note shared without an identifiable byline. The workflow and prompts here are original.